Five Republican candidates for president will meet Wednesday night for a third GOP debate — with the dominant polling leader Donald Trump once again off-screen and trying to upstage the event with a rally nearby.
The debate will take place at the Adrienne Arsht Center for the Performing Arts of Miami-Dade County and air from 8 p.m. to 10 p.m. Eastern on NBC News platforms. It will also be live-streamed on Rumble.
2024 presidential election
End of carousel
The field has narrowed since the first GOP debate in Milwaukee. Former vice president Mike Pence recently dropped out of the race, and former Arkansas governor Asa Hutchinson and North Dakota Gov. Doug Burgum failed to meet the polling and fundraising benchmarks the Republican National Committee required to participate.
Former New Jersey governor Chris Christie, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, former U.N. ambassador Nikki Haley, tech entrepreneur Vivek Ramaswamy and Sen. Tim Scott of South Carolina will be participating in the forum. Here’s what we’re watching for.
Abortion remains a salient issue in the 2024 presidential cycle and the major victories claimed by abortion rights advocates Tuesday in conservative-leaning Ohio and increasingly red Kentucky sent yet another signal to the Republican Party that many of its leaders have sought far more restrictive abortion measures than rank-and-file voters are comfortable with. But the field is splintered over how far into a pregnancy abortion should be allowed — and whether a federal ban is appropriate. Scott and DeSantis have said they would sign a 15-week national abortion ban — though it’s unclear whether they support exceptions in cases of rape, incest or when a pregnancy is life-threatening. Ramaswamy and Christie are not in favor of a federal abortion ban. Haley has held a nuanced position, emphasizing that she would seek consensus on the issue. In one Fox News Sunday interview she said that she would be willing to support a 15-week national ban if the GOP could find the 60 Senate votes needed to pass it, but she noted that garnering that level of support was highly unlikely. Those ideological differences are likely to become a flash point tonight as DeSantis and Scott seek to draw a contrast with Haley on that issue.
Skipping the debate stage (again), the former president is trolling his much-lower polling rivals by holding a counterprogramming event in the predominantly Hispanic suburb of Hialeah as he looks to boost his share of support within that key voter group. But after sidestepping direct attacks on Trump for much of the presidential race, rivals such as Haley and DeSantis have gotten increasingly aggressive as they contrast their governing styles with that of the former president.
When Haley addressed donors and activists at the recent gathering of the Republican Jewish Coalition — which is co-sponsoring the Miami debate — she suggested that Trump has failed to differentiate between good and evil in his dealings with authoritarian world leaders such as North Korea’s leader Kim Jong Un. In a jab at his age, she accused Trump of getting “confused” while speaking about adversaries of the United States and said that America cannot afford “four years of chaos, vendettas and drama.”
DeSantis has also been criticizing Trump by name and suggesting that he is too preoccupied with his personal drama. Expect to see more of those critiques onstage in Miami as candidates flex their willingness to take on Trump.
Millions of potential Republican donors will tune in for the debate, but another key audience — particularly for Haley and DeSantis — are the influential donors who have stayed on the sidelines, watching whether one contender can show the ability to beat Trump at a time when he is leading the field by an average of 50 points. DeSantis and Haley have been engaged in a fierce tussle for second place, and a key poll recently showed the former South Carolina governor pulling even with DeSantis in Iowa, the state his advisers see as the linchpin in his path to victory.
DeSantis was once viewed as the most formidable challenger for Trump — but he has lost that luster as his campaign has struggled with overspending, staff shake-ups and refining a message that failed to connect with many GOP voters. Look for DeSantis to use the debate stage to try to show donors that he is the tougher adversary for Trump in the early contests next year.
Haley and Pence, two more traditional foreign policy hawks, tangled with Ramaswamy in the two previous debates over his suggestion that the United States should eventually phase out aid to Israel, cut assistance to Ukraine and focus on more pressing problems at home. Those exchanges were combative even before Hamas launched its surprise attack on Israel on Oct. 7. Haley will be looking to draw out those foreign policy contrasts with both Ramaswamy and DeSantis, whose views have often tracked with the more isolationist tendencies of Trump’s supporters.
On Tuesday, Ramaswamy announced that any potential appointee in his administration would have to sign a “No to Neocons” pledge. Ramaswamy said that voters interested in “20 more years of endless wars” should choose another candidate and that he was the choice for voters who want “to stay out of no-win wars and make America stronger at home.”
Policy toward China has become a key flash point in the Haley-DeSantis competition. The outside groups aligned with Haley and DeSantis are using ads to try to paint their respective rivals as too cozy with China in their dealings with that nation as governors. Opposition research and a flurry of falsehoods are flying in both directions, and you can bet both candidates will work those attacks into some of their answers on Wednesday night.
A recent campaign ad by SFA Fund, a super PAC backing Haley, charged that DeSantis voted to “fast-track” President Barack Obama’s “Chinese trade deals” — a claim that The Washington Post’s Fact Checker said earned four Pinocchios. On the other side, Never Back Down, the super PAC backing DeSantis, suggested in a recent ad that Haley allowed a Chinese company to “get dangerously close” to a U.S. military base — calling her “too dangerous to lead.” The Post Fact Checker deemed that ad a serious stretch that earned three Pinocchios. As foreign policy takes central stage Wednesday night, expect to see clashes on that topic.
Earlier this year, many Trump foes had hoped that his campaign would falter under the weight of four indictments and his mounting legal bills. Instead Trump has bolstered his lead over his rivals while using every possible opportunity to portray himself to his supporters as a victim of an unfair legal system. After his contentious day in a Manhattan courtroom Monday, he sent repeated fundraising solicitations to fill his campaign coffers.
But Trump rivals such as Christie say they believe that Trump’s legal troubles will look like a greater liability to Republican voters who are worried about beating President Biden as the primaries draw closer. Others such as Haley have argued that the former president’s legal problems will be “a distraction” next year when Republicans are trying to defeat Biden. Trump may have brought his campaign into the courtroom in New York this week, but rivals will make sure voters are reminded of the trouble those legal challenges could present for Republicans next year.